Review: The Keeper of Magical Things, by Julie Leong
| Publisher: |
Ace |
| Copyright: |
2025 |
| ISBN: |
0-593-81593-9 |
| Format: |
Kindle |
| Pages: |
353 |
The Keeper of Magical Things is a cozy fantasy novel. It is set in
the same universe as The Teller of Small
Fortunes, but it doesn't share any characters or plot, they're not
marketed as a series, and so far as I can remember neither book would
spoil the other. It is Julie Leong's second novel.
Certainty Bulrush is a novice mage with one reliable magical ability: She
can talk to objects and occasionally convince them to do small things.
This ability is clearly magical, which means Certainty is indeed a mage,
but this appears to be all that her magic can do. The Guild has
requirements for the level of magical ability required to become a full
mage that go beyond talking stained quilts into unstaining themselves,
which is why Certainty has been a novice for six years.
This by itself is a problem, since Certainty's cohort keeps passing her
by. Worse, though, is that she was counting on the wages of a full mage to
pay for her brother's training to become an apothecary. The thought of
failing him is extremely upsetting. Certainty therefore jumps at an
offered mission to take a cartload of excess magical objects that are
causing a dangerous build-up of energies in the Guildtower to safe storage
in the small and very unmagical village of Shpelling. Successful
completion of that mission will earn Certainty a promotion to Deputy
Keeper and therefore to a full mage.
This is the opportunity she didn't know to hope for. The only drawback is
that she will have to work with Mage Aurelia, the famously off-putting
farspeaker and magical scholar the other novices refer to as the ice
witch.
Aurelia is every bit as icy, formal, and condescending as Certainty was
afraid she would be, Shpelling grows nothing but garlic, and the
inhabitants are suspicious and hostile. The mission could be a disaster if
it weren't for Certainty's stubborn good nature.
It's arguably a spoiler to say that there's an enemies to lovers romance,
but it's hinted at on the cover, mentioned in the publisher's blurb and,
honestly, if you aren't expecting an enemies to lovers romance by a few
chapters in, you probably haven't read many books of this sort.
I found The Keeper of Magical Things quietly enjoyable but
extremely predictable. If you're in the mood for what it's offering, the
predictability may not be a problem, but it was the kind of book where the
direction the plot was headed was so obvious that I got a bit bored
waiting for it to arrive. Certainty has a good heart, humble origins,
limited but specialized magical ability, and a self-esteem problem, and if
you've read much fantasy, you've probably read two or three or a dozen
other books with variations of this protagonist. You know how they
generally turn out, and that is indeed what you're going to get after the
obligatory setbacks and tragedies and looming catastrophes.
Aurelia, similarly, is a variation on a character you've probably met
before. Certainty discovers, not long into the book, that the brilliant
over-achieving mage wears a necklace (supposedly to help her focus) that
constantly whispers to her how inadequate she is and how much harder she
needs to work. The necklace was given to her by her parents. This book is
not exactly subtle.
That said, there's nothing wrong with the characterization. Both Certainty
and Aurelia are interesting characters with rounded-out personalities,
although it takes a while before Certainty (or the reader) is allowed to
see Aurelia's. Their interactions with the inhabitants of Shpelling are
fun to watch in the same way that it can be fun to watch people play
PowerWash
Simulator. You're not in overwhelming suspense about what's going to
happen, but the details are amusing and it is satisfying to watch people
with good intentions slowly fix things. There is a plot, and a villain,
and a not-subtle message about how everyone deserves acknowledgment and
respect, and the hours I spent reading about these characters were
enjoyable.
The problem with this book isn't that there's anything wrong with it, but
that it may not give you more enjoyment than another book you could have
been reading. I quite liked The Teller of Small Fortunes in part
because it surprised me in a few places and the main character felt a bit
different than the typical fantasy protagonist. The Keeper of
Magical Things felt less original and a bit more obvious and predictable.
It was still quietly good-hearted and occasionally charming, and I think
I'll still remember Certainty in a few months, but I'm not feeling the
urge to push it into anyone's hands.
If you're in the mood for a gentle fantasy about finding solutions to
people's problems and waiting out the prickliness of people who
desperately need a friend, you may enjoy this a great deal. Just don't
expect unpredictable twists and turns or a surprising plot structure.
An apparent third book in this loose series, The Isle of Lonely
Monsters, is currently scheduled for publication in 2027.
Rating: 6 out of 10
Log in
Apple Passeig de Gràcia's main floor after remodeling (via Applesfera)
Note: MacRumors is an affiliate partner with Amazon. When you click a link and make a purchase, we may receive a small payment, which helps us keep the site running.
